Cooks Club
History

Pumpkin pie spice is a blend of warm, aromatic spices that were originally brought to Europe from Asia during the spice trade, starting as early as the Middle Ages. In colonial America, these spices became essential in cooking and baking, especially during the autumn and winter months when their warming qualities were most appreciated. Early settlers adopted pumpkin as a staple food because it was easy to grow and store, leading to the creation of spiced pumpkin dishes, which began appearing in cookbooks in the 17th and 18th centuries. However, the idea of "pumpkin pie spice" as a pre-mixed blend didn’t emerge until the 20th century.

Summary 

Our pumpkin pie spice is anything but basic—made of historically rare spices sourced from the renowned Spice Islands and beyond. Indonesian cinnamon lays the foundation with sweet, complex notes and a hint of citrus, while Vietnamese cinnamon adds bold intensity. Nutmeg offers earthy depth, balanced by the zesty bite of ginger. Jamaican allspice brings aromatic warmth, and mace adds a lighter, peppery sweetness. Orange peel’s citrusy zest balances the warmth, while cloves enhance the profile with a sweet-spicy flavor. A touch of Indian cayenne provides a subtle kick, adding a lingering warmth that makes our blend distinctive.

Ingredients 

Indonesian Cinnamon, Vietnamese Cinnamon, Nutmeg, Ginger Powder, Jamaican Allspice, Mace, Orange Peel, Cloves, Indian Cayenne.

Why We Love It 

We love our pumpkin pie spice because it captures the essence of fall. The blend’s versatility is a big part of its charm—it's not just for pumpkin pie anymore. A dash of this spice instantly adds warmth and depth to any dish, making it a kitchen staple during the cooler months. We especially love it in coffee and overnight oats!

The More You Know

Did you know that the first recorded recipe for pumpkin pie dates back to the 17th century? It was more of a pumpkin-filled custard than the spiced pie we enjoy today, but the love for pumpkin-flavored treats has clearly stood the test of time!

Comments 0

Log in to leave a comment.

No comments yet. Be the first!

Recent Stories

Test Kitchen: Our cozy cooking community

World Spice · June 30, 2025

Thank you for a wonderful Tea Fest

World Spice · September 29, 2026

Free shipping with fall baking

Aubrey Koch · September 27, 2026

Recent Recipes

Honey Caramel Sauce
Honey Caramel Sauce

45m · Easy

Baked Chicken Thighs

N/A · Moderate

Rice

30m · Easy

Easy Veggies

10m · Easy

Recent Spice Tips

Cinnamon Toast Spice past the toast

World Spice · September 28, 2026

Two things to shake on buttered noodles

World Spice · September 21, 2026

Homemade syrup

Ɓine McMahon-Grace · September 17, 2026

Cook your spices in the fat first

World Spice · September 14, 2026

Recent Discussions

What are you snacking on right now?

World Spice · October 01, 2026

How do you use Worcestershire?

Linda Elman · September 19, 2026

What's a dish you cook that means "I love you"?

World Spice · August 31, 2026